
There is a phrase that costs Calgary homeowners more than any interest rate. It goes like this.
The crew is already here. The wall is already open. We might as well redo the bathroom too.
Then the laundry room. Then the closets. Then the windows. A renovation that started as one room turns into half the house, and the budget follows it.
Renovations usually cost more than the bid
Every renovation has two kinds of extra cost. The first is the might-as-wells: the projects you add because you are already living in a construction zone. You control those, even if it does not feel that way.
The second is what is behind the walls, and you do not control that at all. The biggest surprises in an older Calgary house are always behind the walls. A house that has been updated a few times can have almost anything in there: old wiring behind new outlets, plumbing joined from two different decades, a past leak that was painted over, an addition sitting on a different foundation than the house. You will not know until the drywall comes off.
So here is my rule of thumb. Get a bid from an experienced contractor, then add a cushion of about a third before you decide whether you can afford it. If the project only works at the exact bid, it does not work.
Personal taste does not sell twice
People renovate partly to make a house theirs, and that is a good reason. Just be honest about what you are buying.
The things that move a home's value are the big ones: the location, the lot, the square footage and the number of bedrooms and bathrooms. Add a bathroom or finish more living space and you will usually see some of that when you sell.
Your taste is different. Design trends turn over faster than mortgages do. The kitchen that looks perfect today will look like a particular year to a buyer a decade from now. Personalising is spending, not investing, and that is fine as long as you call it what it is.
What I would do before opening a wall
- Get the scope in writing. If it is not written down, it does not exist. Track every change order. They add up quietly.
- Get more than one bid, and be wary of the lowest. A price far below the others often means something is missing from it.
- Pay in stages, and hold back the last part until the work is done. Money is your only leverage with a contractor.
- Check the permits. Structural, electrical, plumbing and basement suite work usually needs them in Calgary. Unpermitted work can come back to bite you when you sell, or when you make an insurance claim.
- Visit the site often. Mistakes caught on the day get fixed. Mistakes found after the walls close get lived with.
- Fix the house before you decorate it. Roof, grading, foundation, furnace, sewer line. A beautiful kitchen in a house with water coming into the basement is still a house with water coming into the basement.
Sometimes the answer is to move
Here is the question I would ask before any big renovation: would that money work better as a down payment on a house that already has what you want?
Sometimes the answer is no. You love the street, the school, the neighbours, and the house just needs another bathroom. Renovate.
Sometimes the answer is yes. The list keeps growing, the budget keeps growing, and you are paying to turn your house into a different house that already exists two communities over. Then the cheaper renovation may be a move.
The cheaper version
If you are getting ready to sell, you rarely need a renovation at all. Paint, new light fixtures and hardware, a deep clean, a tidy yard and a few repairs that a buyer's inspector would flag will do most of the work for a fraction of the cost.
If you are weighing a renovation against a move, I am happy to talk it through and pull what homes like yours sold for, with the work done and without. I am Rich Baldy with CIR Realty.
